Payday loansgenetically modified food persuasive speech
sap crm sales and marketing resume
persuasive speech against genetically enginered food
anthropology dissertation writing grants
resume for the post of purchase manager
doctoral thesis on knowledge management
essay about where you see yourself in ten years
computer engineer resume cover letter biomedical
george orwell shooting an elephant essay
fashion buyer internship cover letter
help writing speeches
descriptive study dissertation
dissertation in management and leadership
persuasive essay on why you should be a vegetarian
sales and catering manager resume
dissertation of curriculum development
resume target ottawa
can hand written detection plagiarism gcse
heading for college essay
how to write custom service behavior in wcf
argument essay about global warming
i will never forget essay
diversity thesis pojman
cover letter sales without experience
paragraph about london city
death of a salesman family essay
how to write a scholarship essay about goals
papers writing numbers
optometry school admissions essay
thesis on sex education
woman suffrage movement essay
how to write a literature review for a dissertation proposal
proposal and dissertation help journalism
methodology dissertation how to write
compare resume writers
professional customer service resume objective
write a book report for me
3 sentence essay
forest succession homework help
sales representative position resume
the outsiders essay questions
andrew ng phd thesis
lease vs buy research paper
m tech thesis help
research paper on after sales service
master thesis on derivatives
communication essay introduction
danksagung dissertation englisch
writing prompts
their eyes were watching god essay
descriptive statistics in dissertation
edexcel history coursework help
numerical analysis homework help
hoa budget cover letter
resume for gym sales
english essay writing spm
hvac resume help
airline master thesis
argumentative essay about child care
write my bibliography
academic essay on leadership
apa literature review outline
resume for an electrician helper
technical support customer service representative resume
help with python homework
thesis writing ireland
professional objectives for sales resume
cold contact cover letter customer service
phd research proposal mathematics education
to kill a mockingbird prejudice essay
cv writing services in nigeria
cover letter customer service employment
humorous essay definition
phd dissertation economics harvard
thesis in marketing
resume for service engineer
resume for customer service call center manager
payless sales associate resume
the functionalist view of family essay
fractional order controller thesis
essay help animals
citing sources in essay
purdue university admissions essay
college essay about being gay
master thesis artificial intelligence
essay about family support
pharmacy application essay writing
phd thesis in advertising
evolution of the thesis phd comics
writing my admissions essay village
college essay about being a twin
rhetorical essay definition
what america means to me essay
order to chaos essay in lord of flies
essay writing on education
anu phd thesis abstract
diversity essay contest 2015
resume for agriculture sales
current events essay
essay on personality
how to write an application letter for leave
help with stoichiometry homework
special events sales manager resume
homework help recycling
ruslan salakhutdinov phd thesis
cardiff university dissertation guidance
best holiday essay
how to write a letter of application for work experience
write college application letter
essays writings
engineer malaysia resume sales
multi step equations with fractions and decimals homework help
services marketing phd thesis
auto sales manager resume
literature review on online payment systems
personal leadership essay
a2 english literature coursework help
dissertation standardized testing
phd thesis american literature
my hobby essay
help me write my narrative essay
research paper on buying a car
dissertation proposal construction law
sales trading assistant resume
phd thesis cloud computing
argumentative essay on autism
an essay about respect
resume human services to retail management
duras the lover feminist essay
attention grabbers for essays about yourself
dissertation speech and language therapy
the lottery shirley jackson essay
supply chain management thesis phd
should community service mandatory essay
writing help for esl students
help me write my cover letter
annotated bibliography websites
creating a resume for graduate school admission
thesis e payment system
gender inequality essay
ama doctoral dissertation competition
account executive sales resume
point by point compare and contrast essay
master thesis data mining
florida bar exam essays
ambition in life essay
essay transition words list
harcourt homework helper spelling
help writing lab report on enzyme activity
district manager job description resume
evaluate an expression homework help
homework helper job description
do androids dream of electric sheep empathy essay
essay writer los angeles
distribution manager resume objective
order resume online hooters
graduate admission application cover letter
phd thesis on economic development
cover letter graduate school admission
phd thesis in educational planning
order office supplies resume
dissertation proposal ppt
descriptive writing for high school students
phd thesis dissertation unisa
sales and operations manager resume
holt math algebra 1 homework help
study skills essay writing
essay on my pet dog in french
term paper on chocolate
write a essay about my best friend
essay feminine hispanic in mode woman writer
dissertation consumer behaviour recession
what to write about for an essay for global warming
junior technical writer cover letter
how to write an autobiography essay of myself
research papers in literature
shortest time to write a phd
ap physics b homework help
classification essay on friends
objective on resume for customer service position
surgical sales resume
pharmacy tech resume help
marketing management papers
order of essay paragraphs
narrative essay an unforgettable incident
school uniforms debate essay
essay on night by elie wiesel
car sharing research proposal dissertation
Payday Loans
ICRF v. Maryland Motion to Dismiss: Eleventh Amendment PDF Print E-mail

V - THE ELEVENTH AMENDMENT IS NOT A BAR

TO THIS ACTION

The Eleventh Amendment bars actions against states and their officials in federal court absent consent of the state defendant. However, excepted from this general rule of sovereign immunity is that set forth first in Ex parte Young, 209 U.S. 123, 28 S.Ct. 441 (1908), in which the Supreme Court created the exception by asserting that a suit challenging the constitutionality of a state official’s action in enforcing state law is not so barred, reasoning that an unconstitutional statute does not "impart ... immunity from responsibility to the supreme authority of the United States." Id., 209 U.S. at 160, 28 S.Ct. at 454. Young also held that the Eleventh Amendment does not prevent federal courts from granting prospective injunctive relief to prevent a continuing violation of federal law. Id.; Green v. Mansour, 474 U.S. 64, 68, 106 S.Ct. 423, 426 (1985).

Defendants concede that the Eleventh Amendment does not bar suits seeking to enjoin officials from committing violations of federal law, citing Booth v. State of Maryland, 112 F.3d 139, 142 (4th Cir. 1997). Actually, it is the continuing violation of federal law which triggers the exception to the general rule. Green v. Mansour, 474 U.S. at 68, 106 S.Ct. at 426; CSX Transportation, Inc. v. Board of Public Works of the State of West Virginia, 138 F.3d 537, 541 (4th Cir. 1998).

Defendants argue that since the acts complained of in the Complaint are past and not future acts, that the Report has now been published and the Task Force’s functions are at an end, that the action is barred. As argued in the preceding section, this action is not moot and substantial and important relief continues to be sought by the plaintiffs.

Plaintiffs are not seeking prospective relief, nor are they seeking monetary damages or injunctive relief. This case presents an unusual situation of the legislative act at issue carrying no specific mandate for future conduct, but rather, causing the promulgation of a "Report" under the authority of the State after completion of its inquisition into religious minorities, the very existence of which in its present form causes present and continuing harm as to these plaintiffs and to a large number of persons.

The Resolution and its subsequently created Report promote governmental deference to some religion and derogation of others, enumerated as "cults," or worse, the euphemism "destructive groups." In other words, finding that the term cult was offensive, the Task Force invented an even more offensive term to describe what no one reasonably perceives to be anything other than the "cults," including plaintiffs’ religions, the activities of which the Task Force was mandated to investigate.

Put another way, defendants assert that they are immune from federal suit by the publication of an official report, requested by the legislature, in which some types of religion are criticized as harmful to the public good and others elevated as not harmful to the public good. And public institutions are warned to beware of the type of "destructive" religion, which, in the words of the sponsor of the Resolution, is "manipulative, harmful and have as its goal to prey on naive persons rather than praying for the good of one."

Defendants’ acts cause continuing harm, rendering the controversy alive and requiring that defendants’ arguments be rejected by the doctrine of Ex parte Young.


TABLE OF CONTENTS

I - INTRODUCTION

II – STATEMENT OF FACTS

A. Legislative History of the Cult Task Force Resolution
B. The Task Force Report Continued the Violations of Plaintiffs’ Constitutional Rights

III - PLAINTIFFS HAVE STANDING TO BRING THIS ACTION

IV - THIS ACTION IS NOT MOOT

V - THE ELEVENTH AMENDMENT IS NOT A BAR TO THIS ACTION

VI - CONCLUSION