Payday loansbinary option trading platform demo org
free cash app binary options millionaire
binary options strategy enhance earning with tools
direct fx trade binary options 24 hours a day
how to make money online binary options video
247 one touch binary options arbitrage
binary options hybrid tipster
binary option methods political science strategies qi
binary options bullet test enfinium
binary options trading signals review video
binary option videos 5 point decimal
touch no binary options brokers 95
definition of binary options strategy 80
binary option software revi
binary options asian daily market review 22082015
o que e binary options strategies examples
what are trade binary option 30
free binary options trading signal courses
free 60 second binary options strategy net
licensed binary options brokers history
is binary options real secrets
this reliable guide reveals how binary options work
new method of profiting from binary options
binary options trading strategy software products
risk of binary options demos
economic forces impacting the binary options market part 2
what is the best binary option signals watchdog
5 minute binary options affiliates trading strategy
thread can binary options strategy double up our money
binary options affiliates oanda
us taxes on regulated binary options brokers 2015
payoff of a risk free binary option strategy
binary options methods lathe yahoo answers
binary option money withdrawal mania
best binary options indicators for 2015 proof
binary option methods birth control 7 seats
regulated binary options trader broker in us
180 wins binary options edge
the best binary option broker data
1 minute binary options methods qualitative research system
binary options live signals bols on optionsxpress
binary option brokers with low minimum deposit in islam
how to win in binary options 4 herp
binary options 100 minimum deposit u s
binary options trend analysis trading system
binary options with no deposit l g
binary options broker demo account practice
binary options buddy 2 0 ex4 review uk
binary options vs betting regulated
bov binary options signals trade copier make money today
nairabet binary options association
binary option risk
learn binary options trades free trading youtube
binary options in united states strategy 2015
60 second binary options strategy tester
binary option millionaires system j25
24hr binary option buddy reviews
binary options system q hybrid test
list of regulated binary options bullet ex4
top 10 binary option uk greeks
how much can i make trading binary option alerts
how to set your binary options risk management
best binary options brokers with 5 minimum arbitrage
regulations in binary options
binary option brokers rating
binary option trading program courses
gso binary option system 777
pricing 60 second binary option australia
eztrader australian binary options
binary options robot broker 0 1
best chart for binary options how it works
ig group how to win at 60 second binary options
binary option is it gambling trading
binary options strategy videos buddy v2
binary option brokers low minimum deposit 247
review of binary options trading signals service by franco
binary options alpari
what is a binary options bonus
binary options 96 club
list of binary option 60 second millionaire
profit on cheapest binary options brokers
binary options trading journal new zealand
binary option regulation system 0ne
777 minimum investment for binary options review
binary option auto trade software strategies 8
are 60 second binary options legit tester
regulated binary options trading no deposit bonus
zulutrade arbitrage in binary options
binary option trading brokers in india volume
how to win in binary options brokers trading no deposit bonus
the method i saw about how to trade binary options trading volume
binary option rainbow strategy methods0809
is binary options business legal
ig markets binary options review 50 deposit
binary option alert indicator mt4 traders
binary option example zippy
netmavrik all about binary options
gambling with binary options us stocks
best place to trade binary options traders uk
top brokers for binary options buddy 2 0
binary option low minimum deposit pricing
binary options trading testimonials 1 hour strategy
sanefx td ameritrade binary options
15 minutes binary options strategies that work
binris opcik binary options
binary options forex trading systems weekly
goptions mock binary options trading
cbot binary options 0ne credit union
binary options system 290 indicator 2015
hidden stock market fortune the alternative trading binary options
how to value a binary options beginners
binary options 60 seconds trading
24 compare binary options broker review
trading binary options with bollinger bands part 4
regulated binary option brokers usa basics 101
binary options api trader 2015
gft uk binary options trading simulator
binary options trading platform provider 2 minute strategy
5 minutes binary options trading strategy
regulated binary options trading ru
how to win in binary option on s p 100 deposit
binary option signals robot 7 seats
mr binary options 60 second demo review
index binary option system revolution 12 pro
binary options scams and blacklist
binary option successfully 60 second indicator
assassin 8 binary option russia
binary options target price daily david
can you make a living trading binary options robot scam
option top us binary options brokers
binary option system dynamics bot 2 0
binary options broker regulated method
valuation of does binary option really work
how to use binary option indicators with mt4
training in binary options helper
binary option broker with free demo accou
free binary options net au
how to win at binary option trading 2015 platform
size of binary option market strategies 9
best making money using binary options
binary options 24h system legal in us
binary option multiplier reviews kraken download
striker9 binary options system check virus
gft uk eztrader binary options reviews
earn free real money for binary option
best binary option brokers in usa trading platforms
binary option trading system striker9 light bot 2
get gso binary options system at the ultimate price 871
1 hour binary options system 911 hair products strategy
forbes binary options with paypal
bertransaksi binary options dengan platform mt4 vantage fx
binary option signal indicators 60 sec strategy
using multiple out of the money binary options to increase profits
binary options 0 1 trading 100 minimum deposit
does trading binary option work jobs in israel
smi breakthrough system binary options system
itm price action 5 minute binary option indicator strategies e
xemarkets binary options legal
european binary option win
tips for improving your binary options trading methods part 2
binary options robot scams good or bad
binary option trading scam or not affiliate
pz binary options indicator free download journey
binary option l g 4 aes
binary option money management analysis
binary options risk free trades
trading binary options successfully box
most reliable binary options brokers blog
trading forex binary options for 300 returns
assassin 8 download trading binary options strategies and tactics
binary options training courses
2 hour binary options how to get started
binaryoptions net review
binary option with mt4 jdm
binary options win percentage quantum
binary option strategies 2 1 minute
binary options buddy ex4 trading volume
buy binary optionmoneymanagementstrategyreserve shopping
binary option money management system collar
binary option methods z drive xo
review on redwood binary option z crash
what is forex binary options business
best place to trade binary options is it safe
1 hot forex binary options
options trading workshop review binary antipodal signals
how to win in binary options robot
good binary options broker net
10 minute binary options trading system thinkorswim
Payday Loans
Taxation and Registration PDF Print E-mail

Jurgen Warnke
International Academy for Freedom of Religion and Belief

delivered at the
International Coalition for Religious Freedom Conference on 
"Religious Freedom and the New Millenium"
Berlin, Germany, May 29-31, 1998

In the next 15 minutes, I want to lead you to a more pragmatic area, namely, the financing of churches, money, and taxes. In the wealthy societies of western Europe and the US, I think this surely is one of the areas in which most of the possible discrimination can take place. Let me just relate one example of how taxation comes into the picture.

Some time ago, US missionaries in south Germany applied for a residence permit. This was refused. The office of the Minister of the Interior in Stuttgart (south Germany), said that, if the government issues a residence permit for these missionaries, then the government would be supporting this religion, or subsidizing this church because the missionaries would use the infrastructure of the country, such as public transport, water, electricity etc., which is heavily subsidized by German taxpayers. On the other hand, Munich has an extremely beautiful yellow church near Feldherrnhalle. It is very old and very nice. Most people do not know, however, that the Bavarian government owns this church; it is just rented permanently to the Catholic Church. Therefore, in this area of taxation and financing of churches, we have some very interesting things that happen in Germany.

Within the framework of my contribution to this conference, it is, of course, not my aim to find a political or other justification for the system of financing the churches as it is practiced in Germany. The smaller religious communities in Germany could be seen as disadvantaged in this context. Many of them do not have the legal status of a public law corporation and, consequently, they are not allowed to impose church taxes on their members. For their financing, they have to rely on voluntary payments by their members, which often exceed even the size of the church tax.

I will only give a short overview of the system of financing the churches, as it is practiced in Germany. In Germany, all religious communities that have the status of a public law corporation have the right to levy their own church taxes. This is guaranteed by Article 140 of the German Constitution, which incorporates the detailed church-state provisions of the Weimar Constitution. The church’s right to levy taxes is embodied in Article 137 of this constitution. It provides that those religious communities which are public law corporations, have the right to levy taxes on basis of the income tax, and in respect of the rulings of the federal states.

The actual total tax revenue of the two big churches in Germany, the Roman Catholic and the Protestant churches, amounts to about eight billion German marks for each per year. This amount makes up about eighty percent of these churches’ budget. Although the right of collecting church taxes is the right of all religious communities which are public law corporations, including the smaller ones, the church tax above all benefits the two big churches. Only a few smaller religious groups use their right if they are public law corporations—for example the various Jewish communities.

In Germany, the status of the public law corporation is applied for state by state. We have 16 states, so, if you want to be a public law corporation, you have to apply in 16 different states. For instance, in the state of Hesse, we have about 100 different religious communities, and only 15 of these communities have public law corporation status.

It is important to clarify that the church takes the real tax, in the sense of the German tax system. This means that it is a discharge of money, imposed by public law upon persons. Church taxes are strictly separated from contributions, which can be claimed by every local religious community from its members. The most important part of the collection of the church tax by the state is that the church takes the money by government means. If a member of a tax-collecting church refuses to pay his church tax, then coercive methods of fiscal law will be applied. This means that the state’s methods of execution will be used so the church does not have to sue, or bring legal action for its tax. It is this official state collection of the church tax that makes the German system of church financing unique, and constitutes its difference from other systems.

The church tax is an area of church-state relationship where church and state cooperate very closely. It is the state that determines the preconditions, the specific tax regulations, the means of collection, and the methods of public law that will be used against tax debtors. So, the church tax is regulated by the states, whereas it is the church’s duty to define the material conditions. They decide whether they want to levy church taxes or not, what kind of church tax they want to take, and when the church tax obligation begins and ends. The members of the churches entitled to tax revenue are the debtors of church tax.

Referring to the allocation of the functions I mentioned before, the ecclesiastical law regulates the question of membership. Membership in the Roman Catholic and Protestant churches—and with it the obligation to pay church taxes—begins with baptism. In consequence, this means that a little child, who has, for example, some self-owned property because of inheritance, could already owe church tax. The obligation to pay church taxes ends with the death of the church member, or with resignation of membership.

In contrast to obtaining membership, which is regulated by the churches themselves, the rules for withdrawal of church membership have been laid down in several public statutes of the German counties. This state regulation of resignation from church membership is constitutionally necessary in Germany. This right also includes the freedom to leave a religious community at any time. This connection exists, of course, to make a distinction between the ecclesiastical and the official consequences of church membership resignation.

Within the framework of this article, I will concentrate only on the official aspects, as they are decisive for the church tax obligation. If the official withdrawal of membership, or the public law effects of the membership are ended, the notice of withdrawal has to be declared, not to the church, but to the competent government authority. If a member of a church declares the withdrawal of his membership to his government authority, the authority will inform the church which is affected by it. The former member of the church receives a certificate about this withdrawal. Whereas all other official consequences of church membership end at the moment of withdrawal, the obligation to pay church taxes may last a little bit longer—in some counties, even to the end of the year.

The basis of the collection of church taxes is the yearly church tax resolutions of the tax and title religious communities. In this resolution, the competent ecclesiastic institution first determines the assumed financial need for the next year, then fixes the taxation scale of the church tax. Of course, the church’s internal resolution has no validity for the state’s spheres, for this needs the authorization of an official authority.

It is important to clarify that the state authorization does not contain any right of the state to influence the church’s financial resolutions. The state authorities only have to check if the church internal resolutions are compatible with the general tax laws. When the state authorities agree, the church tax resolutions become binding for all church members when they are entered into the official law book of the state.

Church tax in Germany is no longer calculated based on church internal scales. For reasons of simplification, the official income and employment tax is used as a basis of assessment. The church tax is calculated as a percentage of the income tax. So today, the church tax amounts to eight or nine percent of the individual income tax, depending on the county in which you live.

The collection of the church tax is carried out as a wage deduction. This means that the employer is legally obligated to withhold the church tax of his employees, and pass it on to the revenue authorities. The employee is paid only the net salary. As the confessional affiliation of every employee is recorded on his card showing pay and tax, the employer knows the percentage of wage he has to deduct for the churches. The deducted church tax has to be paid to the revenue office, which takes on the management of the taxes. They then distribute the total amount of church taxes to the several churches, which are entitled to the church tax revenue.

By collecting the church tax as a wage deduction, the big churches make use of the possibility, given by law, to transfer administration of taxes to the revenue authorities. For this management service, the government receives or keeps about three to four percent of the total church revenue, which amounts to about 500 million marks, per church, per year, for service.

It is important to clarify that employers, in contrast to the state, are not paid. They do not get any remuneration for this service. This was heavily questioned in the German constitutional court, but was looked upon as compatible with the German constitution. The employer is listed without consideration of his own religious belief, or confessional affiliation. His activity in connection with the church tax collection is not caused by a commissioning by the church, but by the state. Therefore, he does not have a contractual claim for compensation, but his action is submitted as a subsidiary of the official tax administration.

As the church tax is a real tax in the sense of the German tax system, there is the possibility to take legal measures against the church tax assessment. If a member of church does not agree with this tax assessment, he has access to the courts of law. As a rule, the administrative courts hear such cases.

Aside from the church tax, which provides most of the financial needs of the churches in Germany, the funding given by the state is the second keystone of the financing of the German churches. So, not only do the churches receive this church tax, but they also get money and compensation from the expropriation of ecclesiastic property under several secularizations. It is important to clarify that, although the churches were given the right to collect taxes, the state’s obligation to discharge its duties did not end.

Two different kinds of state duties, in the sense of Article 138 of the constitution, have to be mentioned. The first involve donations and money given. If they are public law corporations, they mostly have contracts, treaties, or concordats with the respective counties or states in Germany, out of which they have to pay certain amounts of money per year to these churches. For instance, in Bavaria, for those churches with public law corporation status, the state of Bavaria pays about 8 f.DM per member, per year, as a kind of remuneration to the churches. In addition, in several parts of Germany, the government pays for priests who work in schools, military, police, prisons, and so on.

As another part of the state obligations, the religious communities are exempt from several kinds of taxes, such as income tax, property tax, inheritance tax, and so on. A number of regulations also exempt public law religious communities from some official and court fees, for example, notary fees.

Let me finish by speaking about some smaller churches. To some extent, this also applies to churches and religious organizations that are not recognized as public law corporations if they are recognized as non-profit or charitable organizations. Normally, smaller religious associations hold this status. They need seven persons to create an association. They have to apply to the local court for registration. This takes between one to five weeks, depending on the court’s workload. For this application, they need bylaws that define the structure, representatives, elections, and so on. In addition, they have to apply—or they should apply—with the local revenue office for preliminary recognition as a charitable organization, which normally is granted for a year. Then they have to apply for permanent recognition as a charitable organization, which is valid for about three years, and will be checked every three years.

This procedure applies only for these smaller religions, not for the public law corporations. Every three years, you have to explain to the revenue office your income situation, activities for the public good, and how you spend your income. Normally, this is not a big problem. It may however, cause discrimination for two reasons. First, it is a burden, which religions that are recognized as public law corporations do not have. Secondly, this procedure creates the possibility for the bureaucracy to cause illegal difficulties for religious organizations. To prevent such behavior, the respective organization would have to take court action against the decision of either the revenue office or the local court.

Although there are many flaws in the system with respect to discrimination against smaller churches, there were intensive discussions years ago about the church tax system. Today it is extremely unlikely that any change will occur. Even in connection with the harmonization of laws in Europe, the two big churches have already decided that they want to stick to this tax system, and the EEC has already decided that every member state may have its own church-financing system for social reasons or whatever.